Herrick High School “Eagles”

At One-Time the Herrick High School Building
A horse pulling a cart

Description automatically generated

The History of Herrick High School

Herrick (population 524) is located in south-central Illinois in the southwestern portion of Shelby County. Herrick sits just north of the Shelby County / Fayette County border on Shelby County Highway 14 at County Road 850E.  County Highway 14 connects Herrick to U.S. Route 51 just five miles to the west.

GREAT history of the town of Herrick can be found at the web address of http://www.galvinfamily.net/Herrick/herrickhistory.aspx . According to this site the town of Herrick was incorporated in 1888. Many businesses were established as well. The first school within the town limits of Herrick was started in 1891.

Information regarding the history of Herrick High School was sent to us by Galen Strain:

“Herrick Community High School with a four year curriculum began in 1920 according to George L. Cherry, Carl Frost, & Verla Boaz.

Mr. G. A. Cook, who was instrumental in its organization states that ours was the first community High School to be organized in Shelby County.  Before that time students who graduated from the 8th grade often chose to study for an additional one, two, or even three years.  Miss Frances Dixon who was principal of the grade school , located on the SW corner of Carroll Park, taught post-8th grade subjects from 1901-1910.  High School work was taught by other grade schools principals from 1910-1920.

In 1937 Orval Moore taught music to both High School & grade School students and a band was organized.  Later Mr. C. Joseph Velasco was another band instructor who had his 34-piece band play at commencement and other school activities. Other Band instructors were Ellis T. Campbell (“Whitie”) and C. Phillips Sandeen.

      A new high school and grade school building were completed in 1937.”

According to the web address of  http://www.galvinfamily.net/Herrick/herrickhistory.aspx :

“Herrick, as John Bumgardner first remembers from his early childhood, about 1925-1935. We shall come to Herrick from the north and proceed south and John will tell what he saw or remembered.

Stopping at the present four way stop and proceeding south two blocks, on the west, was a large two story weatherboarded white building. It was located in then southeast corner of what is now Carroll Park. It was Herrick Grade School. Continuing south, on the west, was and is a large two-story concrete block building with a concrete porch across the entire front. This was Herrick High School for a number of years. John started High School in the fall of 1931.”

So we know that a high school was in place for sure in the early 1930s.  Our guess is that Herrick High School was holding classes byk the 19-teens.  We know that Herrick High School served the community and surrounding farm kids for about 70 years.  The early 1970s brought with them consolidation talks with Herrick’s neighbor to the northeast, Cowden. This effort was finalized for the start of the 1971-72 school year.

The fate of the Herrick High School building is being sought.

Herrick High School Quick Facts

Year opened:                       early 1900s

Year closed:                        1971

Consolidated to:                   Cowden-Herrick High School

Herrick HS team nickname:  the “Eagles”

Herrick HS team colors:       Black & Gold

School Fight Song:              unavailable


We know the Herrick High School boys competed in basketball.  It is probable that baseball and track were offered as well.  Football may have been played at Herrick as well.  Team nickname, colors, school fight song, coach’s names, and team records are all items we are interested in finding out more about Herrick High School.


We are certain that Herrick High School had some memorable seasons in their historic past.  However the school did not win any IHSA Tournament trophies while the boys competed in basketball. The first school gymnasium was erected in 1932 south of the Block Building.  A new school gymnasium was erected in 1952.

1926-28                                                                   Coach L.V. Krutsinger

1928-29   Team won SECOND place in the             Coach    L.B. Story

               District Tournament at Pana

1929 Team Members:  Frank L. Sarver,

               L.G. Corley, Marlin Gregory, Gerald Boaz,

               Oral Pope

1951-52                                                                   Coach Richard Adair

1952-53                                                                   Coach Frank Chismar

1953-60                                                                   Coach James M. Turner

The Herrick basketball program lays claim to one dubious distinction that gained it national attention in the late 1960s and early 1970s.

According to the IHSA website (www.ihsa.org) Herrick High School boys basketball was winless for three straight seasons and the better part of one other.  From February 09, 1965 through February 17, 1970 the basketball program endured a 90 game losing streak.  At that time it was an IHSA state record for consecutive losses that still stands at the second longest losing streak in IHSA history.  The streak included a game against Beecher City in 1968 which Herrick lost 150 – 29.  This game allowed Beecher City to be listed among the top-ten in four other categories in IHSA history.

We are told that the Herrick streak gained national news attention.  It was also suppose to have garnered a mention by Johnny Carson on “The Tonight Show”.

On the Glory Days site, we HATE to focus on the negative.  We KNOW that Herrick High had some great players and seasons prior to the above mentioned streak.  We are truly hopeful that a fan of the site or an alumnus or resident of Herrick will help us with this information.

Do You Have Information Regarding Herrick High School?

If you do, please contact us so we can add it to the Herrick HS page.  Athletics, we know, were not the whole story.  Herrick High may have had band, choir, dances, FFA, FHA, and many other activities which made the experieince of attending there special and unique.  We can be contacted via e-mail at ihsgdwebsite@comcast.net . We can be reached via postal service mail at:

Illinois HS Glory Days

6439 N. Neva St.

Chicago,  Il.   60631

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: